✨ FREE U.S. SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $75! ✨

Indulgent Cookies

Mega stuffed, insanely thick, epically chewy. Whether you’re a chocolate lover, fan of fruity pastries or a classic cookies n’ cream fan, we’ve got a cookie for you!

Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie

Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie

Afterschool snack attacks are getting a major upgrade, and one that all ages will enjoy! Our take on the crispy, frosted and filled pastries you loved as a kid, the Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie is packed with sugar, spice and everything nice. We start with a sweet brown sugar and cinnamon cookie dough base, made ultra thick and chewy thanks to our handcrafted gourmet cashew butter. Each pastry inspired cookie is stuffed with homemade cinnamon flavored buttercream, Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon Pop-Tarts® and premium white chocolate chips. Deliciously topped with white chocolate drizzle and graham cracker crumbs.

$5.19
$6.49
Out of this World Cookie
Out of this World Cookie
Out of this World Cookie
Out of this World Cookie
Out of this World Cookie
Out of this World Cookie
Out of this World Cookie
Out of this World Cookie
Out of this World Cookie

Out of this World Cookie

Chocolate-caramel heaven! We transformed a beloved candy bar into a decadent cookie that’s truly hard to resist! Each Out of This World Cookie starts with a rich caramel cookie dough base, made ultra thick and chewy thanks to our handcrafted gourmet cashew butter. Stuffed with chunks of gooey Milky Way® candy bar and topped with silky milk chocolate drizzle and even more chopped Milky Way® candy, you’ll be left wondering if you’re actually eating a cookie or indulging in the candy aisle.

 

$5.19
$6.49
Starberry Blast Cookie
Starberry Blast Cookie
Starberry Blast Cookie
Starberry Blast Cookie
Starberry Blast Cookie
Starberry Blast Cookie
Starberry Blast Cookie
Starberry Blast Cookie
Starberry Blast Cookie

Starberry Blast Cookie

A blast of flavor so berry refreshing, you’ll be begging for more! Our take on the classic strawberry milkshake pastry pop-tarts that you know and love, this Starberry Blast Cookie is packed with sweet strawberries and strawberry-flavored buttercream. Our incredibly tasty cookie dough base is ultra thick and chewy thanks to our handcrafted gourmet cashew butter, and features Golden Oreos®, premium white chocolate chips and strawberry crunchies. Deliciously topped with strawberry-flavored white chocolate drizzle and pink sanding sugar.


$5.19
$6.49
Fudgin' Around Cookie
Fudgin' Around Cookie
Fudgin' Around Cookie
Fudgin' Around Cookie
Fudgin' Around Cookie
Fudgin' Around Cookie
Fudgin' Around Cookie
Fudgin' Around Cookie
Fudgin' Around Cookie

Fudgin' Around Cookie

Snackers rejoice, we have a cookie inspired by a legendary lunchbox treat! All the flavors of sweet chocolate creme and velvety fudge combine to create our Fudgin’ Around Cookie. We start with a rich PB cookie dough base, made ultra thick and chewy thanks to our handcrafted gourmet peanut butter. Each indulgent cookie is then stuffed with Little Debbie® Fudge Rounds before being delicately drizzled with premium milk chocolate. Sure to leave your taste buds and belly delighted!

$5.19
$6.49
Gimme S'more Cookie
Gimme S'more Cookie
Gimme S'more Cookie
Gimme S'more Cookie
Gimme S'more Cookie
Gimme S'more Cookie
Gimme S'more Cookie
Gimme S'more Cookie

Gimme S'more Cookie

America’s favorite campfire treat, but make it a cookie! Our take on the beloved bonfire ‘sandwich’, each bite of the Gimme S’more cookie is loaded with toasted marshmallow, graham cracker and chocolatey flavor. We start with a sweet marshmallow and graham cracker cookie dough base, made ultra thick and chewy thanks to our handcrafted gourmet cashew butter. Stuffed with homemade marshmallow-flavored buttercream, milk chocolate chips and mini marshmallows. Deliciously topped with rich milk chocolate drizzle, a dusting of crushed graham cracker and marshmallow crumbs.

 

$5.19
$6.49
Dunk A Spoon Cookie
Dunk A Spoon Cookie
Dunk A Spoon Cookie
Dunk A Spoon Cookie
Dunk A Spoon Cookie
Dunk A Spoon Cookie
Dunk A Spoon Cookie

Dunk A Spoon Cookie

Your favorite 90's nostalgic snack has just received a major upgrade! Our take on the classic Dunkaroos® vanilla cookie and frosting combo, the Dunk A Spoon Cookie will take you back to your old cafeteria lunch table one bite at a time. We start with a sweet cake batter cookie dough base, made ultra thick and chewy thanks to our handcrafted gourmet cashew butter. Each one-of-a-kind cookie is stuffed with homemade confetti-flavored buttercream, Golden Oreos®, premium white chocolate chips and pastel bit chips. Deliciously topped with confetti-flavored white chocolate drizzle and more pastel bit chips.

$5.19
$6.49
Butter My Cup Cookie
Butter My Cup Cookie
Butter My Cup Cookie
Butter My Cup Cookie
Butter My Cup Cookie
Butter My Cup Cookie
Butter My Cup Cookie
Butter My Cup Cookie
Butter My Cup Cookie

Butter My Cup Cookie

A true peanut butter lover’s dream! We take everything you love about peanut butter cups, and transform it into a decadent, candy-filled peanut butter cookie. Our tasty cookie dough base is ultra thick and chewy, thanks to our handcrafted gourmet peanut butter, and is stuffed with REESE'S® Peanut Butter Cups and REESE'S® Pieces. Deliciously topped with milk chocolate and creamy peanut butter drizzle.

$5.19
$6.49

Scratch-made, upon order, our Indulgent Cookies offer massive flavor with each bite. The foundation for each cookie begins with a delectable dough built around our silky smooth gourmet nut butters, complemented with just the right amount of premium mix-ins and toppings.